'The biggest disaster since the Romans arrived in Melrose' - Town slams crematorium decision

Alexa Brown • Published 11 Nov 2009 11:19 5 Comments

Share this

FURIOUS campaigners have slammed Scottish Borders Council's decision to allow the building of a crematorium beneath the Eildons as 'the biggest disaster since the Romans arrived in Melrose.'

Ogilvie Dickson, member of the Save the Eildons campaign group, was one of many looking on as the SBC Planning Committee shooed the controversial plans through on Monday with a majority vote of eight to two.

And Mr Dickson, who helped organise a petition carrying more than 1300 signatures opposing Westerleigh Group's plans for the site next to Waird's Cemetery, said the decision would have a huge impact on tourism in Melrose.

He said: "It's an absolute disaster. Not one single councillor took into account the impact that this development would have on the tourism trade in the town itself. Who would want to go on holiday with their family and end up in a hotel full of mourners? It is just not right the right thing to build beside a tourism town."

Mr Dickson also vented anger at plans to play funeral services from the crematorium through speakers to an area outside when the number of mourners exceeds the building's capacity.

He added: "It's inhuman to expect people to stand outside on a cold, January morning and listen to a service through speakers. The whole thing is badly planned, and has been from the very beginning. It has been rushed through without any consideration for the people of the town.

"It is the biggest disaster since the Romans arrived in Melrose."

The council received more than 220 responses to the plans, including two petitions for and against the development.

Scottish Natural Heritage objected to building on the site, which they said is a 'sensitive' part of the National Scenic Area. The matter will now be passed onto Government ministeres who will have the final say on the plans.

But Scottish Borders Council leader David Parker said he was happy that the council had finally agreed on a site, after it was revealed that the Borders is the biggest geographical site in the UK not to offer such a facility.

He said: "I am delighted that the Planning and Building Standards Committee has endorsed the proposals to build the region's first crematorium. We have waited 30 years for the development of this much-needed facility and I am very pleased that the plans have been given the go-ahead and I know the majority of Borderers will entirely agree with today's decision."

Financial Director of the Westerleigh Group, Adrien Britten, yesterday said the company was pleased to have received initial planning permission for the site.

He told the Border Telegraph: "I think the points I'd make are that, first and foremost, we've been looking for a site in the area for over 15 years, and this is the only site that served the need and that we feel is an appropriate site to build a crematorium on.

"It seems as though a major fear of most people in the area has been the additional traffic. I know the figures to be accurate and I really don't think the traffic will be any problem in this area from my past experience.

"Another issue is the speakers for the outside area, but they are only small speakers and will not be heard more than a few hundred yards away. They certainly won't impinge on usage of the cemetery.

"I'd like to assure everybody locally that there should be no fears because we will do our best to be good neighbours as we have been around the UK for the past 20 years."

This article appeared in Border Telegraph 11 Nov 09

Have your say. Post a comment on this article.

amelia philip
Unregistered User
Nov 11, 20:26
Report comment

Here we are again, Mr Dickson mouthing off. What have the romans done to you? If it wasn't for them coming to the borders there might not be any tourists or do you think they only come for the rugby! Granted we do have many other attractions and I don't think a crematorium will be one, BUT The eildons are the ideal place for it being next to the cemetary which I don't think anyone objected to. As for staying in a hotel full of mourners, most wakes are usually in the morning or afternoon and highly unlikely to have anyone staying overnight. I think it's about time you and your friends came into the 21st century, after all they built houses at the foot of the Eildons why not a CREMATORIUM.

NAME TO BE WITHHELD PLEASE THANKS

Recommend? Yes 0 No 0
******
Nov 12, 16:18
Report comment

This comment has been removed by a moderator
******
Nov 12, 16:18
Report comment

This comment has been removed by a moderator
Jim
Unregistered User
Nov 12, 16:19
Report comment

"It is the biggest disaster since the Romans arrived in Melrose. LOL, Ogilvie Dickson, that's a soundbite to end all soundbites!!

What a plonker!

Recommend? Yes 0 No 0
Someone
Unregistered User
Nov 12, 19:12
Report comment

I agree!! What a plonker! As the 1st response states if it wasnt for the romans what would melrose offer!! A burnt abbey, rugby and overpriced shops!! Get a grip!! This is a good thing for the borders and will save people money and a heck of a journey to say goodbye to there loved ones!!

GET A GRIP

Recommend? Yes 0 No 0
Gala Escapee
Unregistered User
Jan 6, 00:29
Report comment

Melrose is home of the NIMBY. All so far up their backsides they don't know when day is night. The place is so dead a Crem might liven things up a bit.

Recommend? Yes 0 No 0
The Rose
Unregistered User
Feb 17, 13:07
Report comment

I'm guessing none of the above comments come from people who live within Melrose. Let's dump a crematorium in your town and see how you react, I feel it may be a different story all together.

Recommend? Yes 0 No 0

Return to the main index, get more from this section or browse our News archives.

Border Telegraph Poll

Do you prefer the new road layout in Galashiels to the old system?

Follow @bordertelegraph