Rachael Hamilton MSP: The 'danger' of scrapping NHS Borders

Rachael Hamilton MSP <i>(Image: Supplied)</i>
Rachael Hamilton MSP (Image: Supplied)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

JOHN SWINNEY'S decision to abolish NHS Borders and reduce the number of health boards across Scotland seems to be a desperate bid to fix deep-rooted problems that have developed in our healthcare system over the last two decades of SNP rule.

On their watch, waiting lists are far too long, patients struggle to get GP appointments and our A&E departments are under enormous pressure, with ambulances often left waiting outside hospitals for hours.

The SNP should not use reorganisation as a sticking plaster to cover up failures that have built up over their two decades in power.

 John Swinney had to do something but redrawing the map and getting rid of NHS Borders is not the answer. It is an extreme proposal that is thin on detail and does not seem to be grounded in evidence.

None of the serious problems mentioned above will be fixed because there will be fewer health boards. The danger is that this becomes another enormous NHS reorganisation which consumes time, money and energy without improving much.

 The loss of local accountability could be very harmful. NHS Borders makes decisions about healthcare with an understanding of the communities it serves.

It will not help health services to transfer responsibility to a larger organisation based further away with more layers of bureaucracy.

There is a particular risk for rural areas like the Borders. Our communities are not the same as Edinburgh or Glasgow. We have different challenges, so why would our healthcare services be lumped in with the central belt?

A one-size-fits-all approach does not work for rural Scotland. Centralisation has been used too often as a means to reduce services in remote communities.

 The public does not want healthcare delivered according to a blanket model. They want services that are designed around the needs of their communities.

They should be concentrating on fixing the frontline problems that people are most concerned about. Instead, almost 12 years to the day since the independence referendum, the SNP are still obsessing about breaking up the United Kingdom.

This week John Swinney held a separatist summit with the leaders of Sinn Fein and Plaid Cymru.

The three nationalist parties are all pushing to split up Britain at a time when people want politicians to focus on more important issues, such as properly sorting out the NHS.

 It is time the SNP finally put all of their attention onto what really matters to you, not their own selfish political goals.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos